Keep the scavenger hunt

[eriannap]

I just hosted my first murder mystery a couple weeks ago. All of my guests absolutely loved the scavenger hunt. I allowed my party ten minutes to solve and find the clues. However, one character found all of the clues, so she was able to do all of the additional murdering! My guests all really wanted to be the ones finding the weapons to get rid of their enemies, so I gave them all a chance at it, and added additional things to figure out.

[2coolbaby]

Drawing weapon cards instead of the scavenger hunt, would actually be more fair to everyone. Each person would get either one action card, one weapon card or a blank. Much more fair than one person getting all the weapon cards.